Sutras
also known as Shastras are supplemental texts which are
short but potent phrases revolving around the
Upanashadic literature.
There are
six Sutras / Shastras and their main objective is to
realise God. The knowledge in these Sutras / Shashtras
is from four Vedas which every Rishi has told in his
respective Sutra / Shashtras.
First, there
is the Mimamsa sutra that
was written by the sage Jaimini who was
a student of Vyasadeva about 5,000 years ago. Mimamsa
means solutions through critical examination, and was
originally expounded by Jaimini in the twelve chapters
of his Mimamsa Sutra.
It clarifies the Vedic principles so a person can focus
on the ways for attaining a good life now and in the
next. This system was traditionally called Purva
Mimamsa, representing the early revered thought.
This is in relation to the study of Vedanta since
Mimamsa was considered the preliminary understanding of
Vedanta philosophy. On the other hand, Vedanta is also
called Uttara Mimamsa,
meaning the conclusion and higher teachings of the
Mimamsa philosophy, because the Vedas are regarded as
self evident scriptures that reveal divine knowledge.
The Mimamsa
system emphasizes the importance of action in terms of
ritual, worship, and duty or dharma as the means of
reaching liberation from karma and the cycle of repeated
birth and death. It explains the essential Vedic issues
and describes the eternal nature of the Vedic texts as
part of the same spiritual energy as God, which are
manifested on earth through the minds of the great
sages. It then continues to clarify the accurate use of
the Vedic mantras for the attainment of happiness and
material facility. Mimamsa is basically a systematized
code of rules for the Vedic rituals and worship used
along with the Vedas
and explains the purpose and meaning of the rituals. It
is especially meant to help householders regulate and
spiritualize their daily lives, while Vedanta is meant
more for those who had grown tired of materialistic
existence and are ready to retire and seriously engage
in spiritual pursuits. Dharma
is considered to be those moral activities that
harmonize individual life with cosmic life.
The Nyaya
Sutra presents the Vedic system of logic as
established by the sage Gautama. This
was written in a question and answer format, like many
of the Vedic Sutras.
Nyaya is a school of logic which regards doubt as a
prerequisite for philosophical inquiry. All other Indian
systems of philosophy use the Nyaya system of logic as a
foundation for reasoning and debate.
The
five principles of the Nyaya
system are:
-
To
present the proposition
-
The
reason for presenting the proposition
-
An
example of it, showing that it is realistic or
unrealistic, depending on the instance
-
Apply
the example of the proposition presented
-
Establish
the conclusion of the proposition.
The ultimate
purpose of the Nyaya system, which is closely linked to
the Vaisheshika system, is to use this process of logic
to establish the ultimate truth, or God, the Supreme
Reality, and to show the spiritual platform is all that
is truly desirable and not the temporary material
creation. It is meant to help one achieve liberation
from karma and material existence by properly
understanding reality, or the difference between matter
and spirit. Nyaya accepts that the only way to
liberation is to obtain knowledge of the external world
and understand its relationship with the mind and self.
Through logical criticism, one can discriminate between
truth and illusion and applying such understanding in
daily life, rid oneself of suffering and attain
liberation. Additionally, this system of logic was
developed to prove the validity of its principles by
analysis and argument to counter the criticism of the
Buddhists, Jains, and Charvakas. However, the Nyaya
system was empirical and mostly relied on perception,
inference, comparison, and testimony as its means of
acquiring knowledge.
The Vaisheshika
Sutra, written in a question and answer format,
was the first work written on this philosophy by Kanada.
Prasastapada later wrote a definitive commentary on this
sutra entitled Svartha
Dharma Samgraha. The name Vaisheshika
comes from vishesha,
which means uniqueness or particularity. Therefore, the
Vaisheshika system is a study of the uniqueness and
qualities of existence, such as the elements, atoms,
their interactions, as well as the soul. But it accepts
only two independent sources of knowledge, which are
perception and inference. It is a sutra
that helps show the futility of life in the temporary
worlds of maya, and the
need for understanding God and to become free from all
karma so that liberation can follow. However, the
knowledge within this sutra
is unnecessary if one already knows that understanding
God and regaining one’s devotional love is the real
goal of life.
The Vaisheshika
Sutra contained several ideas:
-
That
everything is composed of atoms bearing the
qualities of either earth, water, light, or air
-
That the
individual souls are eternal and pervade a material
body for a time
-
There
are nine basic elements, consisting of earth, water,
light, air, ether, time, space, soul, and mind,
which are all eternal in the form of energy
-
There
are seven categories of experience, which are
substance, quality, activity, generality,
particularity, inherence, and non existence.
However, God is not mentioned in the Sutra, but
later commentators included knowledge of God to
complete the system.
Vaisheshika
attempted to integrate philosophical theories with moral
and spiritual attitudes or dharma
which would lead people to good in this life and the
next. However, it did not bring the Supreme Being to the
point of ultimate reality, but as merely an agent of
release from karma and repeated birth and death.
Therefore, the Vaisheshika philosophy is not complete in
its understanding of the Absolute Truth or of material
nature.
The
Vaisheshika theory states that, merely by interactions
between atoms, the elements are formed and thus, the
world and all objects within appear. However, this is
refuted by the Vedanta Sutras.
For example, if atoms are simply inert matter, then
atomic combinations could not properly take place
without some higher directional force. The Vaisheshikas
say, this force is the unseen principle but fail to
explain fully what it is, where it resides, or how it
works. They also say that atoms and relationships
between the atoms of the elements as earth, water, air,
etc., are eternal, but, this would mean that any form
composed of atoms would also be eternal, such as the
material world and all that is in it. However, anyone
can see that this is not the case since everything is
always changing and breaking apart. Even the
Vaisheshikas accept the fact that all bodies and forms
composed of atoms are temporary. In this way, we can
recognize the contradictions in the atomic theory of the
Vaisheshikas.
The Sankhya
philosophy is another system. The principal aim is to
analyze the distinctions between matter and spirit. The
study of the twenty four material elements was
originally developed as a complex science by Lord Kapila,
as elaborated in Srimad
Bhagavatam. But later, there was another Kapila
who presented an atheistic Sankhya system. Therefore, in
other schools of this system, the existence of God is
considered irrelevant. This is because the universe is
regarded as a system of cause and effect. In other
words, the cause of the universe is that which is
eternal but ever changing, or prakriti,
the ever changing material energy. God is eternal and
non changing, so, within this atheistic view of Sankhya
it is considered that God cannot be the cause of the
universe. Obviously, there are limitations in this
analysis, such as not defining where prakriti
came from and how could prakriti,
which is inert, form the material universe without any
guidance, and so on. So, gradually, there were
additional arguments that again led to an acceptance of
God in the philosophy of Sankhya.
The original
Sankhya system, as explained in Srimad
Bhagavatam by Lord Kapila, acknowledges matter
and spirit as two separate principles of reality. Thus,
genuine Sankhya introduces a dualistic philosophy more
developed than the previous three systems discussed so
far. Sankhya analyzed such factors as purusha
and prakriti (spirit
and matter), the creation and development of matter
through excitation of the purusha
(origin of mankind), how the world evolved, how
the modes of nature operate and affect us, how ahankara
(false ego) causes our identification with matter and
bondage to the material world, the five organs of action
and five senses of perception, the subtle elements, the
gross elements, etc.
The goal of
this system is to understand that the real self is
eternal and free, but because of ignorance the soul
identifies with what is temporary and, therefore,
suffers. Through this kind of analysis of the material
world it is expected that one will realize the
difference between matter and spirit and attain freedom
from false identification. After this stage is attained,
release from existence in the material world is reached
through spiritual training, meditation on the real self
and Superself and the practice of yoga.
Yoga is the
next system, which is the application of the Sankhya
system. Sankhya is the theory, and Yoga is the practice.
Yoga, which is essentially theistic, was known many
years before Patanjali. Although he is often given the
credit for it, he merely codified it in his Yoga
Sutras. The complete system of Yoga is very
complex and has many steps to it, each of which must be
perfected before one can go on to the next step. The
purpose of Yoga is to suspend the flickering nature and
internal dictations of the mind. Yoga is also to attain
relief from the pain that exists from such things as
ignorance, which brings attachment, which then leads the
way to fear and hatred, as well as the fear of death.
The practice of Yoga and renunciation is for bringing
freedom from such pains and suffering. Although the
basis of this system may be quite popular, few people
can actually reach the higher levels of self-Realization
through this process in this day and age.
The sixth
sutra is the Vedanta Sutra.
When it comes to Vedanta, many commentaries on it
revolve around the Brahman. The Brahman generally means
the all-pervading, self-existent power. The word "brahman"
is based on the root word "brah",
which means vastness, power or expansion. It also
denotes the Supreme Being, as well as the atman,
the living being, who, when freed from the body, becomes
situated on the level of Brahman, or the spiritual
nature. The concept of the Brahman was, for the most
part, first elaborated in the Upanishads.
Therein we begin to find descriptions from which our
understanding of it grows. It is described as invisible,
ungraspable, eternal, without qualities, and the
imperishable source of all things.
It is
explained that Shankara’s advaita
doctrine was based on the famous passage in the Chandogya
Upanishad (6.10.3), tat
tvam asi, meaning “That thou art.” He taught
that “thou and that” were not to be regarded as
object and subject, but as identical, without difference
(a-bheda), like the
real self (atman).
Thus, anything that was variable, like the body, mind,
intellect, and ego are objects of knowledge and not the atman.
These
concepts were more fully explained on the basis of the Vedanta
sutras. The Vedanta
sutras are a systemization of sutras
or codes for understanding Vedic knowledge. Tthey are
short codes that are later to be explained by the
spiritual master, guru or spiritual authority. By
themselves, without further explanations, it is not easy
to fathom their depths. So it is these commentaries that
contain the additional information about such things as
the Brahman.
Vedanta
means the conclusion of the
Veda or end of all knowledge. Vedanta is also
known as Uttara Mimamsa,
or later examination, and is a companion to the Purva
Mimamsa, or preliminary examination. The Purva
Mimamsa deals with the early portions of the Vedas
and the Uttara Mimamsa
deals with the latter portions. The Vedic tradition,
unlike other religions and philosophies, is rooted in
such remote antiquity that its origin cannot be fully
traced. The Vedic literature explains that it exists in
the form of eternal spiritual vibrations and is present
both within and outside the universal creation.
Vedanta has
been the most influential of the seven main systems of
Eastern philosophy. Though the name Vedanta is often
taken to indicate the impersonalist, nondual or Mayavada
school of thought, it is essentially dualistic theism,
but various commentaries have interpreted it to mean
different things. It was the Sariraka-Bhasya
commentary by Shankara that established the Vedanta as a
nondualistic philosophy, meaning that the ultimate
reality is but one. In this regard, the Brahman and the
Atman (individual souls) are identical, and the Brahman
is the Absolute Reality from which everything manifests
and back into which everything merges. This
interpretation has gained much respect and influence,
but is not the only or ultimate viewpoint of Vedic
literature.
The Vedanta
sutras are like short, condensed bits of
information used as reminders for the spiritual master
in his discussions on Vedic philosophy with a student or
disciple. Each line, therefore, is meant to be
elaborated upon by the spiritual master for the
understanding of the student.
Vedanta
means “the end of knowledge,” or the final
conclusion of the Vedic philosophy. The Vedanta
sutras are also called the Brahma
sutra, Sariraka,
Vyasa sutra, Vedanta
darshana, Uttara
mimamsa, as well as Badarayana
sutra. Vyasa and Badarayana are two names for the
same person who is considered to be the author and
compiler of the major portions of Vedic literature.
The Vedanta
sutras are divided into four chapters with four
divisions each. In each division the theme within is
stated, reasons for it are given, examples are supplied
to uphold the presented facts, the theme is then
explained further for clearer understanding, and finally
authorized quotations from the Vedas
are supplied to support it. In this way, the information
is given in a format meant to show the authenticity and
reliability of the Vedic viewpoint.
The first
two chapters discuss how the material world manifested
from the Supreme and the relationship between the living
entity and the Supreme. The third chapter explains how
one engages in the prescribed duties to perform and how
to act according to the loving relationship we have with
the Lord. The fourth chapter describes the result of
such devotional service (or bhakti),
which is ultimately to attain liberation or return to
the spiritual world.
The first
verse of the Vedanta sutras
states: “athato brahma
jijnasa”, which means, “Now is the time to
inquire about the Absolute Truth.” Why is it time?
Because we are presently in the human form of life and
should utilize it properly since only in the human form
do we have the intelligence and facility to be able to
understand spiritual reality. In animal forms, the
living entities cannot understand such things because
they do not have the brainpower. So we should not waste
this human form of life by pursuing only the animalistic
propensities, such as eating, sleeping, mating and
defending. Therefore, the Vedanta
sutras begin by stating that now is the time for
us to understand the Absolute Truth.
The Vedanta
sutras, however, being written only in codes, can
be somewhat vague and requires a commentary to elaborate
and explain the aphorisms. Practically speaking, some of
the codes are fairly unclear for anyone who is not
experienced in Vedic philosophy. And since Vedanta
comprises the purport of the Upanishads
which contain knowledge of both the personal and
impersonal aspects of the Absolute, therefore, which
commentary on the Vedanta
sutras one reads can make a big difference. Some
commentaries sway toward the impersonal understanding of
the Absolute, while other commentaries sway toward the
personal Realizations. Obviously, to reach a mature
understanding in this regard, one needs to comprehend
both of these viewpoints. In fact, it is stated that
unless one understands all the features of the Absolute
Truth, namely, the impersonal Brahman, the localized
Paramatma or Supersoul and ultimately the Supreme
Personality of God, one’s knowledge is imperfect.
After
studying the previous portions of the Vedic literature,
only when we arrive at this Brahma
sutras or Vedanta
sutras of Srila Vyasadeva do we find an emphasis
on doing Bhakti Yoga, or devotional activities, for
realising God. This means that God is ultimately the
Supreme Person from whom there is the imminent loving
exchange that can be attained by lovingly surrendering
to Him. That devotion and emotional absorption in God is
the process for becoming free from the illusory
attraction and attachments to the material world. This
paves the way for genuine liberation from worldly
existence.
There have
been many commentaries written on the Vedanta
sutras. The most influential were by such famous acharyas
as Shankara, Bhaskara, Ramanuja, Nimbarka, Vallabha,
Madhva, and Baladeva. So, let us review a few of these
to get a better view of the development of the advaita
and dvaita
philosophies.
The other
subsidiary portions of the Vedas
previously mentioned in the Vedangas
have additional texts that further explain that section
of Vedic knowledge. For example, the Kalpa
sutras, which elaborate on the many kinds of
rituals, are divided into four kinds, namely:
The
Shrauta Sutras explain the rituals the priests
engage in, and the details of performing a Vedic yajna,
or ceremony, according to the particular branch of the Veda
with which it is connected. It covers the large and
royal rituals performed by kings, such as the ashvamedha
or rajasuya, to the
ordinary ones performed by a family, such as the agnishtoma,
agnihotra, or the pitri
yajna for the dead relatives.
The
Grihya Sutras describes the general and
ritualistic social traditions that are usually observed
by householders for their upliftment. These include such
things as the performance of daily worship, study of
scripture, or installing a Deity in a temple. Also, how
to greet a guest, do rituals for moving into a new house
or timely samskaras for
giving a name to a child or the ritual for a child’s
first hair cutting, a youth’s acceptance of a Vedic
order, or the marriage ceremony.
The
Dharma Sutras deal with the different disciplines
or duties of a person, from common individuals up to the
king. This includes duties of people in the four orders
of life (from birth up-to renunciation, or brahmacari
student to sannyasa),
along with duties of a man to his family and society, or
duties of a married couple to each other and their
children, or duties of a king to his subordinates.
The
Shulba Sutras were only a portion of the broader
system of mathematics found in the Kalpa
sutras. These consisted of arithmetic and algebra
as well as geometry. In fact, geometrical instruments
dating back to 2500 BC have been found in the Indus
Valley, which was also a part of Vedic society. The
Pythogorean theorem was already existing in the Shulba
Sutras before Pythagorus presented it. This means
he may have only learned of it through his travels in
India rather than inventing it himself.
Vedic
mathematics is found in the Shulba
Sutras, which means codes of the rope since
particular lengths of rope were used to make exact
measurements. The Shulba
sutras had 1180 branches and give mathematical
details on size and shape of altars for the fire rituals
and the place where such ceremonies would take place.
These mathematical codes are said to have been compiled
from the 8th to the 5th century BC, however such codes
probably existed far earlier than this. It is figured
that the original Indian mathematical developments arose
from the needs of their religious ceremonies that
required altars of precise measurement. This started to
gain significance when the sages began to emphasize the
use of external processes of worship and ritual as an
additional means to attain internal awareness and
spiritual progress. In other words, they were not
interested in math outside of what it could do for them
spiritually. The Shulba Sutras
show the earliest forms of algebra as used by the Vedic
priests.
It was the
Vedic system that developed the decimal system of tens,
hundreds, thousands, etc., and how to take the remainder
of one column of numbers over to the next. The numeral
system of nine numbers and a 0 made calculations very
easy. Without the invention and use of 0, many of the
mathematical advancements that have been made in the
West would not have been possible. These numbers were
developed from the Brahmi script and became popular
after 700 AD, spreading into Arabia. They became known
as the Arabic numerals because the Europeans, who had
adopted them, got them from the traveling Arabians. Yet
the Arabians called them “Indian figures” (Al-Arqan-Al-Hindu)
because they had received them from India. Because of
this it was called the India art (hindisat).
Thus, the system of math that we all use today had its
start in Vedic India.
Further
developments in mathematics in India by its
mathematicians, such as Brahmagupta (7th century),
Mahavira (9th century), and Bhaskara (12th century) in
such areas as algebra and trigonometry were not known in
Europe until the 17th and 18th centuries. In fact, many
of the great inventions made in Europe that we take for
granted today, would have been impossible if they had
been stuck with their cumbersome Roman numerals, and
without the advanced system of mathematics that came
from India.
The
Anukramanika is another book in the same category
as these sutras and
relates the contents of the Vedas.
It consists of 1180 books for the 1180 Vedic branches.
It lists all of the Vedic Gods and their associated
mantras, and all the sages who composed them. So this
works like a summary of the Vedic books.
Beyond these
are many other texts that include the Sraddha
kalpa, Pitrimedhasutras,
Parisistas, Prayogas,
Karikas, etc., all of
which deal only with Vedic rituals.
A later text
that also deals with the Vedic rituals is the Rigvidhana
by the sage Shaunaka. This book gives explanations on
the usage of many of the verses or hymns in the Rig
Veda. The precise chanting of particular verses
produces specific magical or quick results, such as
overcoming one’s enemies, getting rid of disease,
protecting oneself from ghosts, and many other things.
The Rigvidhana
indicates which verses, and the procedure if necessary,
to be used to accomplish their various effects.
Additional
topics, such as alchemy, are also dealt with, or
architecture as found in the Sthapatyaveda,
or erotics as found in the Kama
Sutra.
India also
had a long agricultural heritage that went back to
before 3700 BC, and had the first written texts on the
topic. One of the oldest books is the Krishi
Parashara (c. 400 BC), which means “Agriculture
by Parashara”. This has been translated by the Asian
Agri-History Foundation in Secunderabad, India. This
book gives lists of tools to be used, ways of predicting
rain by using basic astrology with climate conditions,
methods of good farming management for the high yield of
crops, management of cattle, along with advice on seed
collection and storage, etc.
Another text
on agriculture was the Kashyapiyakrishisukti
by Kashyapa (c. 700-800 AD). This describes the means of
producing certain crops, cattle management, soil
properties, laying out gardens, means of irrigation,
marketing, ways of support from the government, as well
as mining, and even a personal code of conduct for
farmers.
The Vrikshayurveda
(The Science of Plant Life) by Surapala was another book
that appeared later (c. 1000 AD). This dealt with the
application of Ayurveda to various kinds of trees.
However, it also contained knowledge of raising
orchards, seed management, selection of soil, ways of
irrigation, finding groundwater, using fertilizers,
dealing with plant diseases and so on. These books
recommend practical ways of efficient farming while
preserving the world’s resources and environment,
along with the means by which humanity can achieve the
essential aims of life, such as dharma,
artha, kama
and moksha (religion,
economic development, sensual fulfillment, and
liberation through spiritual advancement) which are all
things that we should still consider today.